As countries push for renewables and new technologies such as solar panels or electric cars become ever more accessible, it seems as if the house of the future is set to be self-sufficient, independent from the grid, feeding its inhabitants’ needs with green energy from the sun.
At the Université libre de Bruxelles, Faculty of Sciences, Aero Thermo Mechanics, researchers led by Guilherme Silva and Patrick Hendrick have been focusing on the problem of home energy self-sufficiency for a long time and have come up with interesting results, recently published on the Applied Energy journal under the title “Lead-acid batteries coupled with photovoltaics for increased electricity self-sufficiency in households”.
They started by crunching up-to date Belgian data from the Royal Meteorological Institute, energy suppliers and installers and then ran these numbers through their simulation models. They came to the conclusion that energy self-sufficiency in homes with solar panels and certain battery systems may come with an expensive price tag and that there may be better solutions out there to go green.
The problem starts with the bad timing of solar energy and energy consumption: while the sun shines at its maximum around midday, most homes consume the most in the morning and in the evening. Add to that the fact that in many countries most of the solar energy is available in the summer months and you’re set for dark times. No matter how many solar panels are added up, the maximum attainable self-sufficiency will be around 40%. The good news is that 40% self-sufficiency is achievable at prices close to the grid ones, given the recent strong reduction in the cost of solar panels and their long lifetime.
To go beyond 40% self-sufficiency, energy storage seems the natural answer. The researchers coupled the solar panels with lead-acid batteries and the results were striking: all of a sudden, the energy consumed became really expensive. Trying to reach a self-sufficiency of 60% can easily cost twice as much as using the grid. And the lead-acid batteries’ short lifetime and high price are not the only ones to blame: installation costs and extra required electrical equipment also play an important role.
The lack of a long term energy policy keeps homeowners and installers cautious, afraid to invest and bear all the risks, a problem that recently granted Belgium a public reprimand from the International Energy Agency. The researchers also took a look at the impact on the power grid of home solar and energy storage systems. They believe that homes equipped with such systems place a greater strain on the power grid, resulting in peak power consumption from the grid remaining constant while increasing load variability. They concluded that an increase in self-sufficiency would be accompanied by lower utilisation of power plants which would result in higher wholesale electricity prices during no sunshine hours
Power plants will need to be able to answer to quicker variations in demand. All this will impact power grid prices, a field where research is still lacking.
The paper points out that a hybrid approach must be taken for a sustainable energy use. Using several energy sources helps to balance out each one’s disadvantages. Consumption can also be adapted through intelligent appliances that can adjust to the conditions available, as can the energy storage system work in a more intelligent way. Recent energy storage technologies, such as li-ion batteries, continue to enjoy strong price reductions while the share of electric vehicles continues to increase.
With all due respect to the researchers, we have no idea why they used lead-acid batteries for this study, unless they wanted to prove that this technology should not be considered for home energy storage. The only problem is that to our knowledge, no one in the industry has ever recommended lead-acid batteries for this application. The use of lithium-ion batteries for home energy storage purposes is not a very recent development.
Anyone considering a home solar and energy storage system should do their homework regarding their location, electricity prices, installation costs, etc…. While this study was interesting, it is not necessarily applicable to all countries or regions. It does highlight one very important point, however, and that is that the impact distributed energy systems have on utilities, and why they will continue to fight their use.
Guilherme de Oliveira e Silva, Patrick Hendrick. Lead-acid batteries coupled with photovoltaics for increased electricity self-sufficiency in households. Applied Energy 178: 856-867 (2016)
This post was prepared by Solar Thermal Magazine staff.